Alrighty…Here We Go
As much as I love Seattle and the beauty and great wine of Washington, I might just have to boycott the entire state if this unbelievably lame initiative were, by some idiotic chance, to pass.
I mean, I understand where they’re going, but saying, “it should be good fun to see the social conservatives who have long screamed that marriage exists for the sole purpose of procreation be forced to choke on their own rhetoric” is short-sided, because to further the cause of same-sex parenthood, you sacrifice childfree-by-choice couples, those struggling with infertility and married couples with children who honestly, would be better off divorced…among many, many others. I don’t care what you do, but don’t drag my lifestyle choice into your battle…because your proposal is such a slippery slope…and you’re making assumptions that may sound like out-of-the-park hits, but what happens if you’re wrong?
Don’t want to have kids? Sorry, your marriage won’t be recognized. Can’t have kids biologically and plan on adopting? Sorry, your marriage won’t be recognized, either. Forget the fact you’ve been married 5…10…however many years. By some stroke of circumstance, did you have to have a hysterectomy at 17? Forget about marriage. Husband beats you? Sorry, because you have children, under this initiative, you couldn’t get divorced. What about the couple where the woman is past childbearing age; i.e., post-menopausal? Sorry, but thanks for playing.
Having said all that, what happens…let’s say…if the court doesn’t strike these initiatives down as unconstitutional, as the supporters assume? Guess whose lives are altered forever? Ours…not theirs. Their situation doesn’t change a bit. They’re no better or worse off than they are now. Those people affected by this initiative will now need to band together and circle the wagons and organize, while the supporters of this initiative sit back and watch social conservatives choke on their own rhetoric.
Are you willing to sacrifice yourselves for their cause?
Initiative 957
If passed by Washington voters, the Defense of Marriage Initiative would:
- add the phrase, “who are capable of having children with one another†to the legal definition of marriage;
- require that couples married in Washington file proof of procreation within three years of the date of marriage or have their marriage automatically annulled;
- require that couples married out of state file proof of procreation within three years of the date of marriage or have their marriage classed as “unrecognized;â€
- establish a process for filing proof of procreation; and
make it a criminal act for people in an unrecognized marriage to receive marriage benefits.
You know what this means, of course. Callie & George had better pick up the pace. Time’s a wastin’.





4 Responses to “Alrighty…Here We Go”
By Manic Witch on Feb 15, 2007 | Reply
So if you are unable to produce a child in 3 years, your marriage is “invalid” and you get to remarry? And if in THAT marriage you fail to produce an heir, *viscious circle*. How many times to you get to play “Fruit my Womb” before you have/get to pull the plug?
And of course, all this does is bring us back to the dark ages, where a woman’s only purpose is to create heirs. And it encourages living together without benefit of marriage, since of course, a marriage without kids is not recognized anyway.
Assholes.
By Jaynee on Feb 15, 2007 | Reply
I think that’s a ridiculous law and I would be shocked if it passed in ANY iteration.
By Becky on Feb 15, 2007 | Reply
I honestly hadn’t even heard of this yet, but I don’t think anyone in a state like this would take it seriously. There are far too many married couples without kids that wouldn’t tolerate that. Plus, we get to vote on just everything that enters the legislative mind.
Btw, when I go to click on “comments,” your post disappears off your page. I just blindly clicked in the area and fortunately, it worked.
By Stacy on Feb 15, 2007 | Reply
I have no doubt it won’t pass either, but the sheer fact it exists gets me all worked up.